While incentive plans might seem like a natural fit for fundraising roles, there are several reasons why they can be problematic. Here are the top five reasons why putting fundraisers on an incentive plan is generally not advisable:
1. Misalignment with Donor Ethics and Expectations
Many donors expect their contributions to support the mission, not individual compensation.
Tying pay to fundraising performance can create ethical concerns, particularly if donors feel their gifts are being used to enrich individuals rather than support the cause.
Transparency issues may arise if donors perceive that fundraisers have personal financial incentives in securing gifts.
2. Focus on Short-Term Gains Over Long-Term Relationships
Successful fundraising relies on relationship-building, stewardship, and cultivating major donors over time.
Incentive-driven fundraisers may push for immediate donations rather than fostering sustainable donor engagement.
This short-term focus can harm an organization’s long-term revenue strategy.
3. Risk of Unintended Consequences and Perverse Incentives
Incentives might encourage fundraisers to prioritize high-dollar gifts over diversifying the donor base.
Some may overpromise results, leading to unrealistic expectations or failed donor commitments.
It could lead to high-pressure tactics, damaging the organization’s reputation.
4. Challenges with Fair and Equitable Measurement
Fundraising success often depends on external factors (e.g., economic conditions, donor capacity, organizational reputation).
It’s difficult to measure an individual’s direct impact versus team or leadership contributions.
If the incentive structure isn’t equitable, it can create resentment among team members who play support roles.
5. Potential Legal and Compliance Issues
Some nonprofit watchdog groups (e.g., the Association of Fundraising Professionals) discourage or prohibit commission-based fundraising.
The IRS frowns upon excessive fundraising-based compensation, as it could risk a nonprofit organization’s tax-exempt status.
Depending on the structure, incentive pay could violate ethical standards or create conflicts of interest.
Alternative Approaches - Instead of incentive pay, consider:
1. Offering competitive base salaries with mission-driven incentives (e.g., retention bonuses, professional development support).
2. Recognizing fundraisers through non-monetary rewards (e.g., career growth, public acknowledgment).
3. Aligning compensation with overall organizational success rather than individual fundraising results.
#NonprofitLeadership #FundraisingEthics #CompensationStrategy #DonorTrust #PayEquity #NonprofitFinance #HR #FundraisingTips #TotalRewards #MissionDriven #compensation #hr #humanresources #compensationconsultant #incentives